If you’ve been grinding the Cooking Event in Grow a Garden and Chris P. just craved a pie, you’re in the right place. My guide covers every pie recipe—from the easiest Common Pie to the ultra-rare Transcendent Pie — plus step-by-step cooking instructions, ingredient sources, and pro tips to maximize your rewards.
It doesn’t matter if you’re a new player or a seasoned farmer; this complete breakdown will make sure you never waste ingredients again.
What Is the Cooking Event in Grow a Garden?
The Cooking Event is a limited-time activity in the popular Roblox game Grow a Garden. In it, an NPC named Chris P. — a hungry pig — requests a specific food item every hour. Your job is to cook that dish in the green cooking pot and feed it to him before the craving changes.
The better the rarity of the dish you serve, the better the rewards you earn. Rewards can include exclusive crops, pets, and rare items like the Taco Fern and Gourmet Egg.
Pie is one of the most popular dishes in the Cooking Event because it’s relatively easy to make at multiple rarity tiers — and a Prismatic Pie is one of the most cost-effective high-tier recipes in the entire event.
What You Need Before You Start Cooking
Check these basics before adding anything to the pot:
- Use a green cooking pot because pie recipes only work in a green pot. Don’t use any other pot because it will waste your ingredients; before you start, you must check it.
- First collect all the important and needed ingredients in your inventory, then go to the cooking area.
- Know Chris P.’s current craving—If he’s not craving pie right now, a Common or Rare recipe will cook him a smoothie instead. The only recipes that guarantee pie production regardless of the craving are mythical and higher pie recipes.
How To Make Pie in Grow a Garden: Step-by-Step
Here’s the simple process every time you want to cook a Pie:
- Grow or collect all the required crops from the list below.
- Walk to the cooking area at the center of the event lobby.
- Must ensure green cooking pot is ready or empty.
- Equip each ingredient from your inventory and submit them to the pot one by one.
- Wait approximately 8 minutes for the pie to finish cooking.
- Press E to collect the finished pie from the pot.
- Equip the Pie and walk up to Chris P. to feed it to him.
That’s all there is to it. It’s hard to find the right ingredients, especially for the rarer recipes.
All Pie Recipes in Grow a Garden (Every Rarity)
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| 🍎 Apple | 1x |
| 🌿 Any Common Crop | 1x |
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| 🍎 Apple | 2x |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| 🍎 Apple | 1x |
| 🥥 Coconut | 1x |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| Recipe 1 | |
| 🍎 Apple | 1x |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| Recipe 2 (Alternative) | |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| 🌸 Ember Lily | 1x |
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| Recipe 1 — Best Value (Seed Shop only) | |
| 🥥 Coconut | 1x |
| 🌿 Beanstalk | 1x |
| Recipe 2 | |
| 🥥 Coconut | 1x |
| 🌶 Pepper | 1x |
| 🍓 Elder Strawberry | 2x |
| 🫐 Celestiberry | 1x |
| Recipe 3 | |
| 🍏 Sugar Apple | 3x |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| Recipe 1 — Most Efficient Prismatic in Game | |
| 🥥 Coconut | 1x |
| 🌸 Bone Blossom | 2x |
| Recipe 2 (Alternative) | |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| 🌸 Bone Blossom | 4x |
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| Recipe 1 | |
| 🥥 Coconut | 1x |
| 🌸 Bone Blossom | 4x |
| Recipe 2 (Alternative) | |
| 🎃 Pumpkin | 1x |
| 🌸 Bone Blossom | 4x |
Where To Get Each Ingredient
Getting the ingredients is often the trickiest part. Here’s where to find each one:
- Apple — Available in the Seed Shop and from Common seed packs. Easy to grow.
- Pumpkin — Available in the Seed Shop. A staple crop every player should have stocked up.
- Coconut — Available in the Seed Shop. Uncommon rarity but reliably restocked.
- Pepper — Available in the Seed Shop. Uncommon rarity.
- Sugar Apple — Rare drop from apple trees. Keep an eye on the shop rotation.
- Beanstalk — Available in the Seed Shop. Legendary rarity but not difficult to obtain.
- Ember Lily — Mythical rarity. Check the Seed Shop rotation or trade with other players.
- Elder Strawberry — Has a very low chance (0.24%) of appearing in the Seed Shop. Best obtained through trading.
- Bone Blossom — Rare ingredient not sold in the Seed Shop. Obtain through trading with other players or by receiving it as a gift. This is the key ingredient for all Prismatic recipes.
Celestiberry — Mythical rarity. Obtainable from meteorite impact sites in-game.
Pro Tips to Maximize Your Pie Rewards
These tips will help you get the most out of every Cooking Event session:
Cook the highest rarity you can. Always aim for the best Pie you can make with available ingredients. A Prismatic Pie gives dramatically better reward chances than a Mythical one.
Stockpile before the craving hits. You don’t need to wait for Chris P. to crave Pie before you cook. Pre-cook several Pies and keep them ready in your inventory. When the craving hits, immediately hand them all in.
Use the Divine Pie trick. If you’re running low on Bone Blossoms, mass-produce Divine Pies using Coconut and Beanstalk. Both are Seed Shop items, so they’re easy to restock. Feed multiple Divine Pies at once when Chris P. craves Pie for stacked rewards.
Bigger crops = better rewards. The weight of your ingredients matters. Use mutated or larger-sized crops when cooking to increase the food item’s weight, which improves reward quality. The new Grandmaster Sprinkler helps grow larger crops.
Don’t waste Bone Blossoms on other recipes. Since Pie offers the most efficient Prismatic recipe in the game (just 1 Coconut + 2 Bone Blossom), save your Bone Blossoms specifically for Pie when possible.
Match the craving. If you feed Chris P. the exact food he’s craving, your reward chances improve significantly. Keep an eye on his hourly craving timer and time your feeding accordingly.
Pie vs. Smoothie: What’s the Difference?
Many Pie recipes use the same or similar ingredients as Smoothies. The key difference is Chris P.’s current craving:
- If Chris P. is craving Pie — Common and Rare recipes produce Pie.
- If Chris P. is craving anything else — Common and Rare recipes produce Smoothie instead.
Mythical and higher Pie recipes always produce Pie regardless of the craving. So if you want to guarantee a Pie, use at least a Mythical-tier recipe.
Frequently Asked Questions
Always use the green cooking pot. Pie cannot be cooked in any other pot.
Approximately 8 minutes from the time you add the ingredients.
Yes, but only with Mythical or higher recipes. Common and Rare Pie recipes will produce a Smoothie if Pie isn’t the active craving.
1x Coconut + 2x Bone Blossom. It’s the cheapest Prismatic food recipe in the entire Cooking Event.
Bone Blossom is not sold in the Seed Shop. Get it through player trading or as a gift from another player.
Yes. Larger, mutated crops produce heavier food, which improves your reward quality from Chris P.
Final Thoughts
Making Pie in Grow a Garden is one of the smartest ways to farm Cooking Event rewards — especially if you can get your hands on Bone Blossoms for Prismatic Pies. The Divine Pie (Coconut + Beanstalk) is an excellent backup strategy when rare ingredients aren’t available, and stockpiling cooked Pies before a craving hits is the number one tip for serious reward farming.
Use this guide as your go-to reference every time a Pie craving hits, and you’ll always know exactly what to cook and how to get the ingredients.
Good luck feeding Chris P., and may your rewards be Prismatic!
More helpful articles are here:
1 thought on “How To Make Pie In Grow A Garden”